Boris Johnson has lashed out at 'gloomy' predictions of coronavirus woe, telling MPs they were too negative because they were made before last week's vaccine breakthroughs.
The Prime Minister made the comment as he addressed anxious backbenchers last night in the wake of Rishi Sunak's spending review, which revealed the scale of the problem facing the nation.
In grim forecasts yesterday, the Office for Budget Responsibility said debt is on track to hit an eye-watering £2.8trillion by 2025. Merely to stop it rising as a proportion of GDP will require a fiscal tightening of between £21billion and £46billion a year by that time - with the situation even worse if there is no post-Brexit trade deal.
But the OBR's forecasts were made before Pfizer, AstraZeneca and Moderna revealed that their vaccines had high success rates, raising hopes at least one will be approved for use within weeks, with the others to follow early next year.
The Chancellor ducked questions on how he will fill the black hole left in the public finances by the crisis, with economic 'scarring' meaning the government will be spending far more than it is bringing in for years to come.
But this afternoon the Prime Minister's official spokesman committed to the so-called ' tax lock' from the 2019 Conservative manifesto. It pledges no increase in Income Tax, VAT or national insurance contributions (NICs) before 2024.
'We remain committed to the manifesto pledge,' he said.
Extraordinarily, the respected IFS think-tank has suggested that the OBR's scenario is too optimistic, because Mr Sunak has not pencilled in any spending on coronavirus beyond next year.
The IFS believes that Sunak will need to find £40billion a year in tax rises and spending cuts by the middle of the decade if he is to restore balance to the nation's finances.
The Prime Minister, who will hold a press conference this evening, told Conservative MPs last night that the new measures were going to be 'very tough'
Chancellor Rishi Sunak, pictured yesterday, is injecting huge sums into the economy but has been accused by IFS director Paul Johnson, right, of forgetting Covid after 2021 and not mentioning Brexit at all
The government is forecast to borrow at least £100billion in every year of the OBR's forecast period
By 2025 the UK's debt pile will have hit an eye-watering £2.8trillion - and will still be more than 100 per cent of GDP
The national debt is set to rise to £2.27trillion this year, growing to 105.2 per cent of the size of the economy
Sunak defends public sector wage freeze
Rishi Sunak delivered a staunch defence of the public sector pay freeze today saying state workers enjoyed a 7 per cent premium even before coronavirus hit, and the gap is widening.
The Chancellor insisted he could not completely shield government employees from pain amid mass job losses and cuts in income for the private sector.
From March to September, year-on-year private sector wages dropped by 1 per cent, whereas public sector pay rose 4 per cent.
Unveiling his spending review yesterday, Mr Sunak announced pay will be frozen for around 1.3million public sector workers next year, but NHS workers and those in the lowest paid jobs will still get an increase.
However, the news drew fury from unions, while Labour accused ministers of a 'kick in the teeth' for state staff.
In a round of interviews this morning, Mr Sunak said public sector wages have been 'generally higher' than those in the private sector.
He said the 'disparity' existed before the coronavirus crisis, and that 'even when you take into account characteristics and pensions, there was at least a 7 per cent pay premium for public sector'.
He told Sky News: 'That pay premium has certainly widened in the last six months, because what we've seen over the last six months is private sector wages have fallen by a percent and public sector wages have risen by around 4 per cent.
'On top of that, people in the private sector are losing their jobs, their hours are being cut, they are being furloughed – none of that is happening in the public sector.
'So given the context, I couldn't justify an across the board, universal pay increase for the public sector.'
Unions have warned the Chancellor that there would be a chance of industrial action if he went ahead with the move.
Meanwhile, Labour said capping salaries would be an 'absolute kick in the teeth' for frontline workers after their efforts during the coronavirus crisis.
In a round of interviews this morning Mr Sunak refused to say how he might deal with the crippling shortfall in funding, admitting the situation is 'not sustainable' but he will wait for 'certainty' on the economic outlook.
'It wouldn't be appropriate for chancellors – any chancellor – to speculate about future tax policy because that has real-world implications,' he said.
'As you would find from any chancellor, they would talk about fiscal policy at a Budget, and obviously we will have one in the spring – we normally have them in the autumn.'
Mr Sunak said the scale of borrowing undertaken this year is 'not sustainable' but that 'now is not the time to address that'.
'Once we get through this and we have more certainty about the economic outlook we will need to look at how we can make sure we have a strong set of public finances.'
The OBR revealed yesterday that borrowing will hit almost £400 billion this year, with government spending topping £1trillion for the first time as the damage caused by the coronavirus pandemic was predicted to cost every UK household £2,500 in lost income.
Borrowing is set to remain above £100billion a year into the middle of the decade, and debt will remain worth more than annual GDP.
As long as interest rates remain low servicing the debt should not pose a problem.
However, the OBR cautioned that the economy will not recover to pre-pandemic levels until the end of 2022. And due to the hammer blow to key industries, by 2025 UK plc will still be 3 per cent to 6 per cent smaller than was expected before coronavirus hit.
That gap - worth between £20billion and £46billion - that will need closing to prevent debt continuing to soar out of control.
However, the IFS has questioned whether the Chancellor was being too optimistic - because he hasn't allocated any spending for tackling Covid-19 after the end of 2021.
Others questioned why he failed to mention Brexit at all.
IFS director Paul Johnson said: 'Rishi Sunak has been spending truly astonishing amounts of money this year and plans to continue to do so next year in response to Covid.
Rishi Sunak's spending review: at a glance
- The Government has spent an estimates £280billion this year protecting the country from coronavirus.
- Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecasts economy will contract 11.3 per cent this year, the largest fall in output in more than 300 years.
- Borrowing this year to hit £394billion, the highest ever in peacetime.
- Rishi Sunak tells MPs 'this is an economic emergency' and the damage will be 'lasting'.
- 'Long-term scarring' means, in 2025, the economy will be around 3 per cent smaller than expected in the March Budget.
- OBR says unemployment will peak in second quarter of 2021 at 7.5 per cent, with 2.6million people out of work.
- Public sector pay rises will be 'paused' in 2021, but more than a million doctors and nurses will get a salary increase, as will worst-off.
- The 2.1 million public sector workers who earn below the median wage of £24,000 will be guaranteed a pay rise of at least £250.
- Chancellor said there was a disparity between public sector and private sector wages, adding he 'cannot justify a significant, across-the-board' for state workers
- National Minimum Wage will increase 2.2 per cent to £8.91 per hour, including for over 23s.
- Foreign aid budget cut from 0.7 per cent to 0.5 per cent in 2021, will return to higher level 'when the fiscal situation allows'.
- Creation of UK Infrastructure Bank to be based in Northern England, starting work in the spring
- Levelling-Up Fund worth £4billion for local projects in towns and cities across the country
'Yet this was a spending review in which he reduced planned spending into the future, cutting more than £10billion per year from departmental spending plans next year and for subsequent years.
'He has also allocated precisely nothing for Covid-related spending after next year. And these plans assume that the temporary increase in Universal Credit will not continue beyond this year. Each of these assumptions is questionable.
'It seems more likely than not that spending will end up significantly higher than set out today, and so borrowing in 2024-25 will be considerably more than the £100billion forecast by the OBR. Either that or we are in for a pretty austere few years once again, or for some significant tax rises.'
Unveiling his crucial Spending Review, the Chancellor declared that billions of pounds will be pumped into getting the unemployed back to work, as well as boosting infrastructure, the NHS and defence, in a bid to create a platform for recovery.
But in a bloodcurdling message about the problems to come as he disclosed that the immediate response to the crisis has cost £280billion, Mr Sunak told the Commons: 'Our health emergency is not yet over and our economic emergency has only just begun.'
Any hopes of a 'V-shaped' recovery from the pandemic went out of the window with the OBR's assessments.
While the watchdog expects output to have slumped by 11.3 per cent this year, it will only grow by 5.5 per cent next year, 6.6 per cent in 2022 and 2.3 per cent in 2023. Susannah Streeter, senior analyst at investment platform Hargreaves Lansdown, said: 'This is a brutal assessment of the damage wreaked on the economy by Covid-19.
'But desperate times need desperate measures and sustained government spending is vital to help the economy climb out of the abyss.'
There was one ray of light in the OBR's projections – it predicted fewer would lose their jobs than it was forecasting in the summer. The watchdog thinks unemployment will now hit a peak of 7.5 per cent by June next year. However this will still mean that around 2.6million are out of work.
Mr Sunak said of yesterday's spending review, which sets out the next steps for the country's finances: 'Our health emergency is not yet over, and our economic emergency has only just begun.'
The pandemic will permanently 'scar' the economy and blast a gaping hole in the public finances, an official watchdog warned yesterday.
In a bleak set of forecasts, the Office for Budget Responsibility said national output will shrink by 11.3 per cent this year – the largest fall in three centuries. It will not return to its pre-virus levels until the end of 2022.
On the central forecast, growth returns next year but there it takes until the end of 2022 to reach pre-pandemic levels
The three years of lost growth will push down living standards and cause joblessness to rise, it added.
By the end of the OBR's forecast period in 2025, the economy will still be 3 per cent below where it was expected to be had the pandemic not happened.
The permanent 'scarring' is caused by firms abandoning investments, others collapsing entirely and workers making do with lower wages.
With state borrowing at its highest levels since the war, the national debt will continue to climb over the next five years, hitting £2.8trillion by 2025-26.
The OBR's principal forecasts were based on a vaccine not becoming widely available until mid-2021 and strict restrictions remaining in place until then.
The watchdog admitted last night that it had written its forecasts before news of the AstraZeneca jab broke.
This means its best-case scenario – in which a vaccine is rolled out from spring next year with lighter restrictions until then – is now more likely.
Under that assumption, the economy may return to its pre-virus peak by the end of 2021 and scarring could be avoided.
The OBR said: 'The coronavirus pandemic has delivered the largest peacetime shock to the global economy on record.
'The UK economy has been hit relatively hard by the virus and by the public health restrictions required to control it.
'The virus has also exacted a heavy and mounting toll on the public finances. In our central forecast, receipts this year are set to be £57billion lower, and spending £281billion higher, than last year.'
Government borrowing will hit £394billion this financial year, equivalent to 19 per cent of national income.
This is the highest level since 1944-1945 and close to the peak of 27 per cent seen in the Second World War. The Treasury will still be borrowing £100billion a year at the time of the next election in 2024.
The national debt is set to rise to £2.27trillion this year, growing to 105.2 per cent of the size of the economy.
Mel Stride, Tory chairman of the Commons Treasury committee, said tax rises would be inevitable to plug the enormous gap in the public finances.
He urged Chancellor Rishi Sunak against making any big decisions until economic activity started to recover.
The MP added: 'The Government has done a good job in getting us through this crisis. But some of the expected decisions on tax might feel uncomfortably close to the election.'
Rishi Sunak will need to find £40BILLION a year in tax rises and spending cuts by the middle of the decade if he wants to balance the books in the wake of the coronavirus crisis, says IFS as it warns UK is in 'uncharted territory'
Rishi Sunak will need to find £40billion a year in tax rises and spending cuts by the middle of the decade if he is to restore balance to the nation's finances, the respected Institute for Fiscal Studies think tank warned today.
The Chancellor said yesterday at the Spending Review that the UK's 'economic emergency has only just begun' as official forecasts showed the economy will shrink by 11.3 per cent in 2020 because of the coronavirus crisis.
That is the biggest economic contraction in 300 years, with ministers on course to borrow an eye-watering £394billion this year to keep the country afloat - the highest amount ever recorded in peacetime.
The Government's spending watchdog, the Office for Budget Responsibility, suggested in its central forecast that Mr Sunak would need to find £27billlion in tax rises and spending cuts to balance the books.
But IFS chief Paul Johnson said he believed the figure could be significantly higher as he argued the Chancellor had likely been too optimistic in some of his plans.
Mr Johnson said he believed Mr Sunak will end up having to spend more on public services, the coronavirus response and on welfare than he has set out.
The think tank boss said the UK's finances were in 'wholly uncharted territory' but he predicted the long term impact of the pandemic will be 'way less painful than the impact of the financial crisis'.
Paul Johnson, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said Rishi Sunak could have to find £40billion in tax rises and spending cuts by the middle of the decade if he want to balance the books
Mr Johnson said Government spending and borrowing during the coronavirus crisis meant the UK economy is in 'wholly uncharted territory'
Mr Johnson told a briefing today that he was not convinced by the OBR's central scenario for how the next five years could play out.
He said the Spending Review was 'pretty austere' with non-Covid public spending set to fall by more than £10billion next year and in subsequent years.
Mr Johnson said it is 'not obvious that either the need or the appetite for public spending has diminished since March' and that 'frankly I would be most surprised if these plans were adhered to'.
He also questioned the Chancellor allocating £55billion next year for the Government's coronavirus response but allocating 'precisely zero for subsequent years'.
He said he 'wouldn't bet on' the UK not having to spend any money on Covid-19 issues beyond next year.
He also suggested the Government could be forced to U-turn on a decision not to extend a temporary increase in the value of Universal Credit.
He said: 'Put these pressures together and my central scenario would have borrowing at least another one per cent of national income higher in 2024-25 and subsequently, even given the perhaps relatively benign central economic scenario outlined by the OBR.
'In that case if the Chancellor did want to aim for current budget balance he’d eventually need a two per cent of national income fiscal tightening – about £40 billion in today’s terms.'
Mr Sunak has refused to be drawn on potential tax rises, insisting this morning that 'future fiscal policy' would be a matter for a future Budget.
The Chancellor told MPs yesterday that the 'long-term scarring' from the coronavirus crisis would mean that in 2025 the economy will still be approximately three per cent smaller than had been expected in March this year.
Mr Johnson said the economic damage done by the pandemic to the nation's finances was 'record-breaking, breathtaking, huge' and that the UK is now in 'wholly uncharted territory'.
But he said there was 'some reason for reassurance here' because the long term impact is not expected to be as bad as that caused by the 2008 financial crash.
He said: 'Obviously it is not great news but the OBR’s central scenario has only a three per cent long term hit to the size of the real economy.'
He added: ‘Now, a three per cent hit to the economy is obviously painful, especially after such a long period of poor income growth and especially given the hit we have had from Brexit.
‘But it is way less painful than the impact of the financial crisis.’