United Kingdom

NHS trust wins bid to overturn landmark puberty-blocking drugs ruling

An NHS trust has won a Court of Appeal fight to overturn a landmark ruling over the use of puberty-blocking drugs for children with gender dysphoria.

Last year, the High Court ruled it was "highly unlikely" that a child aged 13 or under would be able to consent to the hormone-blocking treatment and that it was "very doubtful" a child of 14 or 15 would understand the long-term consequences.

The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust, which runs the UK's only gender identity development service for children, brought an appeal against the ruling in June.

In a judgment on Friday, the Court of Appeal said it was inappropriate for the High Court to give the guidance, finding it is for doctors to exercise their judgment about whether their patients can properly consent.

The original case was brought by Keira Bell - a 24-year-old woman who began taking puberty blockers when she was 16 before later "detransitioning" - and the mother of a teenager who is on the waiting list for treatment.

Following the ruling Ms Bell said she was "surprised and disappointed" in the decision but said she had no regrets in bringing the case.

She said: "I am obviously disappointed with the ruling of the court today and especially that it did not grapple with the significant risk of harm that children are exposed to by being given powerful experimental drugs.

"I am surprised and disappointed that the court was not concerned that children as young as 10 have been put on a pathway to sterilisation."

"It has shone a light into the dark corners of a medical scandal that is harming children and harmed me," she continued.

In their ruling, the Lord Chief Justice Lord Burnett, with Sir Geoffrey Vos and Lady Justice King, said: "The court was not in a position to generalise about the capability of persons of different ages to understand what is necessary for them to be competent to consent to the administration of puberty blockers."

They added: "It placed patients, parents and clinicians in a very difficult position."

During the two-day appeal earlier this year, the Tavistock's lawyers argued the ruling was "inconsistent" with a long-standing concept that young people may be able to consent to their own medical treatment, following an appeal over access to the contraceptive pill for under 16s in the 1980s.

However, Jeremy Hyam QC, representing Ms Bell and Mrs A, argued policies and procedures at the Tavistock "as a whole failed to ensure, or were insufficient to ensure, proper consent was being given by children who commenced on puberty blockers".

Human rights group Liberty, which intervened in the appeal, said the High Court had imposed a serious restriction on the rights of transgender children and young people to "essential treatment".

The Court of Appeal heard the Tavistock does not provide puberty blockers itself but instead makes referrals to two other NHS trusts - University College London Hospitals and Leeds Teaching Hospitals - who then prescribe the treatments.

John McKendrick QC, for the other trusts, told the court the median age for consenting to puberty blockers is 14.6 for UCL and 15.9 for Leeds.

Football news:

Pique to a gay player who has made a coming-out: The football world is lagging behind, and you are helping us move forward. Thank you
Juventus was offered to sign Witzel as a free agent in the summer
Vinicius was racially abused during the match with Barca. La Liga will inform the prosecutor's office
Kristoffer Ayer: According to the level of Liverpool's attack, it seems as if they don't notice some of the opponent's players
In Barca, they are dissatisfied with the game of Pique, Alba and Busquets. Some players may be sold after Koeman's dismissal
Messi and Mbappe missed PSG training before the match with Lille
Merson on Sulscher: Anyone else would have been fired by now. He is as lucky as a coach can be