Love Island fans have urged Mary to dump Toby after tuning into Sunday night's episode of the ITV2 dating show.
Toby shocked Abigail when he strolled back into the main villa on Friday night holding hands with new girl Mary.
The pair met during the boys' stay in Casa Amor and instantly hit it off - with Toby not seeming too bothered about his partner Abigail.
Toby and Abi had only been in a couple for a few days, but she decided to stay loyal to the footballer - despite lots of new boys moving into the main villa.
The sportsman appeared shocked when he realised Abi hadn't coupled up with anyone new, and looked like he was starting to have second thoughts.
Speaking to Mary in the garden, Toby asked her how she felt about now being in the main villa.
"It’s good, I’m excited, until I saw Abi on her own," Mary replied.
"I never even thought that were an option at all. She doesn’t think that it’s not a thing, she obviously felt like there was a serious connection there for her not to re-couple with someone. Have I missed something?"
Looking sheepish, Toby replied: "It’s a mad one. I didn’t expect it at all to be honest. Personally I thought she was deffo with someone else and I was content with that."
He then asked Mary: "How would you feel if she said I wanna still get to know Toby?"
"Obviously I wouldn't be happy, not at all. Like you brought me back in here and I thought we were sweet," Mary said bluntly.
"There can't have been that much there with you two before because you would have mentioned it," she added.
"It's a difficult one," Toby replied, as Mary appeared frustrated.
Viewers were not impressed with Toby at all and took to Twitter to comment.
One person tweeted: "Mary you are too sexy for this. Dash Toby away. #LoveIsland."
A second posted: "Mary may be the only one with sense but 3 girls with the same story involving Toby says it all! #LoveIsland."
Love Island continues tomorrow at 9pm on ITV2.